Trump Loses Again: 9th Circuit Says Muslim Ban Must Go
Much was said and read this week about the reputation of the federal 9th Circuit Court of Appeals as the country waited for word of whether President Donald Trumps executive order on travel, immigration and refugees would be reinstated.
One side of the courts reputation is a purported liberal bias. That may be overstated, according to scholars cited by the Associated Press. Another facet of the reputation centers on, depending on ones views, the courts activism or overreach. (Conservative radio personality Rush Limbaugh has labeled it the 9th Circus.)
Key Words: Trump says courts seem to be so political
In any event, it provides the brothers or sisters of the robe, in Sen. Ben Sasses recollection of Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuchs phrasing, a disproportionate voice in public life, as Benjamin Wittes, editor-in-chief of the the legal blog Lawfare and a Brookings Institution fellow, writes:
Lawyers dream about becoming judges, particularly 9th Circuit judges, to write opinions like this. Benjamin Wittes, LawfareWittes goes on to note that a grain-of-salt reading of the 9th circuit decision may be well-advised, as the grounds on which this order was fought are not the grounds on which the merits fight will happen.
See: Appeals court rules against Trump on immigration ban
And: Clinton tweets 3-0 after ruling against Trump travel ban
Wittess Lawfare post caught the presidents attention, which Wittes in turn engendered a Wittes response:
Source: http://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-9th-circuit-is-every-lawyers-dream-job-2017-02-10
